India and Pakistan share pattern of deadly hospital fires, exposing state neglect
This digest was compiled by AI from multiple sources — links to the originals are below.
Three newborns died in a fire at a government hospital in Amravati, India, and 14 newborns died in a fire at a maternity ward in Islamabad, Pakistan, within two days. Both fires exposed similar institutional failures, including delayed rescue and inadequate fire safety. The tragedies highlight a pattern of state neglect in both countries.
Key Facts
- Three newborns died in a fire at a government hospital in Amravati, Maharashtra, India, caused by a faulty ventilator.
- Fourteen newborns were killed in a fire at a maternity ward in a prominent state hospital in Islamabad, Pakistan, caused by an exploding air conditioner.
- In India, the AMRI Hospital fire in 2011 killed 89 people and the SUM Hospital fire in Bhubaneswar in 2016 killed 24 people, with no convictions.
- In Pakistan, a fire at Services Hospital in Lahore killed 10 newborns in 2012 and another 11 infants died at Sahiwal Teaching Hospital in 2024.
- The author has covered hospital fires in India and Pakistan for 26 years and observes no regulatory improvement.
The Recent Fires
A fire in the neonatal intensive care unit at a government hospital in Amravati, Maharashtra, killed three newborns. Two days later, a fire in the maternity ward of a prominent state hospital in Islamabad killed 14 newborns. The reported causes were a faulty ventilator in Amravati and an exploding air conditioner in Islamabad. In both incidents, rescue teams arrived late and emergency evacuation was hampered by basic fire-safety failures.
Pattern of Institutional Failure
Politicians in both countries expressed sorrow and announced high-level inquiries, financial compensation, and fire safety audits. The author notes that hospital fires in India and Pakistan have caused significant loss of life over 26 years without regulatory change. In India, the AMRI Hospital fire in 2011 killed 89 people and the SUM Hospital fire in Bhubaneswar in 2016 killed 24 people, with no convictions. In Pakistan, a fire at Services Hospital in Lahore killed 10 newborns in 2012 and another 11 infants died at Sahiwal Teaching Hospital in 2024.
Government Priorities
The fires occurred in India's wealthiest state and Pakistan's capital, indicating that the problem is not limited to remote areas. The author argues that both nations have the knowledge and wealth to prevent such tragedies but choose not to make meaningful improvements. The refusal to improve hospital safety is described as a political choice that treats the lives of poor and vulnerable families as expendable.
1 source
Time · lag behind first